Never miss what is happening in Warren County
Events, new openings and weekend plans from every corner of Warren County. Straight to your inbox, free.
Ask anyone in Hackettstown where to eat and you will get a long list and a strong opinion. We pulled together the spots neighbors keep recommending, all in town or just off Main Street, so you can settle the “where should we go tonight” debate a little faster.
Quick note before you go: a few longtime names have changed hands or closed over the past year, so every place below was checked against its own website this month.
Vote now
Stella G’s
- Where: 186 Main St., Hackettstown
- Best for: Breakfast and lunch
Stella G’s is the breakfast answer for a lot of Hackettstown. The menu runs from egg platters, omelets and eggs Benedict to breakfast tacos, breakfast burgers and bread pudding French toast. Their scratch made scones have been baked daily for more than 20 years, and lunch brings sandwiches like the short rib and the pulled pork panini.
Pandan Room
- Where: 100 E. Moore St., Hackettstown
- Hours: Open daily, 11 a.m. to 8:30 p.m., per the restaurant
- Phone: 908-850-5999
Chef Jay Chai’s Pandan Room serves Thai and Indonesian food made fresh to order, with vegetarian, vegan friendly and gluten free options. It is BYOB, and reservations are recommended, especially on weekends. Chef Jay also offers private cooking classes if you want to learn a dish or two.
Mama’s Cafe Baci
- Where: 260 Mountain Ave., Hackettstown
- Best for: Italian dinners, groups and live music
Mama’s has been voted the best Italian restaurant in Warren County by NJ.com, according to the restaurant. You can sit in the main dining room, catch live entertainment in the Cafe Baci lounge, or book the Rainbow Room for a private party. The menu carries one of the area’s biggest lineups of gluten free, vegetarian and vegan dishes.
Marley’s Gotham Grill
- Where: 169 Main St., Hackettstown
- Best for: Wings, burgers and game nights
Chef and owner Bruno Pascale runs this Main Street grill, best known for its chicken wings. You can order pickup or delivery through their website or app, and Marley’s also hosts private parties.
Main Street Cafe (Versac)
- Where: 103 Main St., Hackettstown
- Hours: Monday to Saturday, 6 a.m. to 8 p.m., per the cafe
This family run spot serves homemade Colombian food and coffee from the owners’ own family farm in Colombia. Come early for breakfast, or try the bandeja paisa, a full plate of beef, chicharron, chorizo, eggs, beans, rice, sweet plantains, avocado and arepa. The skirt steak churrasquito is another favorite.
Grand Avenue Tavern
- Where: 109 Grand Ave., Hackettstown
- Best for: A casual dinner and a drink
The former Bea McNally’s is now a full service tavern with a wide beer, wine and cocktail list. The casual menu covers burgers, hot dogs, chicken wings, flatbreads and salads, and the tavern also hosts catered events and private parties.
The BBQ Pit
- Where: 7 Naughright Rd., Hackettstown
- Good to know: Meats are smoked daily and sold until they run out
Brisket, ribs and pulled pork are smoked low and slow here, the way the BBQ Pit has done it since 2001. Because everything is served until it is gone, the crew says to get there early. They also cater, from drop off trays to big events.
Little Tokyo
- Where: 207 Mountain Ave., Hackettstown
- Phone: 908-850-1188
Little Tokyo serves Japanese and Korean dishes prepared fresh each day. It does not serve alcohol, but you are welcome to bring your own beer or wine.
Want a drink with dinner?
Hackettstown’s Main Street also has a growing brewery scene. Our guide to Warren County breweries and distilleries covers where to grab a pint before or after you eat, and our classic Warren County diners list has the late night and early morning options.
Neighbors, did we miss your go-to? Tell us your favorite Hackettstown restaurant and we may add it to the next update.
Photo: Famartin, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons
Get Warren County in your inbox
The best events, new openings and things to do, once a week. Free.






