Home Warren County Best Pizza in Warren County NJ: Neighborhood Pizzerias
Warren CountyFood & Drink

Best Pizza in Warren County NJ: Neighborhood Pizzerias

Share
Margherita pizza on a plate
Share

Never miss what is happening in Warren County

Events, new openings and weekend plans from every corner of Warren County. Straight to your inbox, free.

Subscribe free

Every town in Warren County has a pizza place people will defend to the end. Here are the neighborhood pizzerias that keep coming up when locals trade recommendations, organized so you can find one close to home for a Friday night pie.

Vote for the Best of Warren County 2026Pick your favorite pizza, coffee, restaurants and more. Voting closes December 7.
Vote now

La Bella Via, Phillipsburg

  • Where: 41 Third St., Phillipsburg
  • Style: Brick oven, thin crust

La Bella Via is a family owned Italian restaurant with a custom built brick oven. Its thin crust pizza uses imported Italian flour, a family sauce recipe and a blend of whole milk and part skim mozzarella. Homemade pasta is on the menu too, and there is a back room for parties. Dine in or take out.

La Bella Via

Rocco’s Pizza and Italian Restaurant, Phillipsburg

  • Where: 360 S. Main St., Phillipsburg

Rocco’s has been in the same family for close to two decades. The dough is made fresh throughout the day on site, the mozzarella is cut and prepared daily, and the sauce is made in house from Italian tomatoes.

Rocco’s Pizza

Alpha Pizza and Sub Shop, Alpha

  • Where: 1408 Third Ave., Alpha

A family pizza restaurant since 1975, Alpha Pizza and Sub Shop covers pizza, cheesesteaks and wings, with homemade Italian dishes on the menu as well. They have their own app for quick ordering.

Alpha Pizza and Sub Shop

Terranova Pizzeria and Trattoria, Allamuchy

  • Where: Panther Valley Mall, County Route 517, Allamuchy

Family owned and serving the community since 2004, Terranova is the go-to pizza stop for Panther Valley. It works for takeout or a sit down Italian meal.

Terranova

Sal’s Pizza, Washington

  • Where: 1 W. Washington Ave., Washington
  • Phone: 908-689-6336

Right in downtown Washington, Sal’s takes orders ahead online, which makes it an easy pickup on the way home.

Mamma Maria Pizza, Washington

  • Where: 433 Route 31, Washington
  • Phone: 908-652-9890

Out on Route 31, Mamma Maria is a convenient choice for Washington Township neighbors, with online ordering available.

Little John’s Pizza, Belvidere

  • Where: 401 Water St., Belvidere
  • Phone: 908-475-8556

A neighborhood pizzeria on Water Street in downtown Belvidere, with online ordering for pickup.

Little Italy, Belvidere

  • Where: 539 Route 46, Belvidere
  • Phone: 908-332-0737

Little Italy serves pizza and Italian dinners along Route 46 and takes orders ahead online.

Prontos Pizzeria and Restaurant, Hackettstown

  • Where: 1965 Route 57, Hackettstown
  • Phone: 908-813-0624

On the busy Route 57 stretch in Mansfield, Prontos is an easy stop for a pie or a full Italian dinner.

Before you head out

Pizzeria hours change with the seasons, so give your pick a quick call before a big order. Looking for a sit down dinner instead? See our guide to the best restaurants in Hackettstown.

Which Warren County pizza is the best? Neighbors never agree, so tell us yours.

Photo: Shisma, CC BY 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Get Warren County in your inbox

The best events, new openings and things to do, once a week. Free.

Share
Written by
Nicole Marino

Nicole Marino is from the Somerset and Warren area and has a love for farms, animals, and all things local. An animal lover at heart, she enjoys discovering local farms, exploring the outdoors, and highlighting the communities that make New Jersey special.

Related Articles
Made in Hackettstown bench in downtown Hackettstown, Warren County NJ
Warren CountyCommunity

New Businesses in Hackettstown NJ: Fall 2026 Openings

Hackettstown welcomed a new Chipotle, a tea parlor, a florist, a boutique...

Best Restaurants in Hackettstown NJ: Local Favorites
Warren CountyFood & Drink

Best Restaurants in Hackettstown NJ: Local Favorites

Where Hackettstown neighbors actually eat, from scratch scones on Main Street to...

Port Murray Historic District in Warren County NJ, the village near Well-Sweep Herb Farm
Warren CountyThings To Do

Christmas in the Country at Well-Sweep Herb Farm 2026

Well-Sweep Herb Farm in Port Murray celebrates Christmas in the Country through...

Gracias and Feliz Navidad holiday wines from Villa Milagro Vineyards in Warren County NJ
Warren CountyFood & Drink

Villa Milagro Holiday Wine Release 2026 in Warren County NJ

Villa Milagro Vineyards releases its Gracias and Feliz Navidad holiday wines over...

Wooded trail through Jenny Jump State Forest in Warren County NJ
Warren CountyEvents

Guided Hikes in Warren County NJ: Nov and Dec 2026

Five free guided hikes with Warren County Park Naturalists at White Lake,...

Boat on the lake at Camp No-Be-Bo-Sco in Hardwick NJ, the Friday the 13th filming location
Warren CountyEvents

Friday the 13th in Blairstown 2026: Camp Tours and Screening

Celebrate Friday the 13th where the 1980 film was shot, with a...

Downtown Blairstown NJ, home of the Roy's Hall concert venue on Main Street
Warren CountyEvents

Live Music in Warren County NJ: November 2026 Shows

Live music in Warren County this November, from a Grateful Dead tribute...

Homemade apple galette with a flaky crust, the kind of bake taught at Warren County NJ holiday classes
Warren CountyEvents

Holiday Workshops and Classes in Warren County NJ 2026

Four hands-on holiday classes in Warren County this November, from flaky pie...